As a business owner, you're likely no stranger to making financial decisions. But when it comes to strategically building long-term wealth, one question often arises: Should I invest through a SIPP or ISA?

Both of these tax-efficient investment wrappers are powerful - but they serve different purposes. In this article, we’ll dig into how each of them work and which you should choose based on your goals and business structure.

What is an ISA?

ISA stands for Individual Savings Account. This account serves as a tax-free wrapper for your savings and/or investments. In a separate post, we cover all the ISA types, rules and deadlines but here are the key points of an ISA:

• 5 types: You can invest via a Cash, Stocks & Shares, Lifetime, Innovative Finance or Junior ISA (you can contribute to 1 of each type)
• Contributions: Made using post-tax, personal funds (no tax relief)
• Annual allowance: £20,000 (across all of your own ISAs).
• Access: Anytime (specific rules for Lifetime ISAs)
• Tax on investments: All income and gains you accrue are free from capital gains tax (CGT), dividend tax and income tax.
• Withdrawal tax: 100% tax-free

This table shows important ISA rules depending on the type of ISA you choose:
‍

What is a SIPP?

SIPP stands for Self-Invested Personal Pension. This is a type of personal pension that allows you to control how you invest for retirement. SIPPs also provide some serious benefits for directors of limited companies. In another article, we cover the 10 Benefits of a SIPP for Business Owners in the UK but here are the key points of a SIPP:

• Contributions: Made with pre-tax funds directly via company or personal funds with tax relief (essentially “pre-tax”)
• Employer contributions: Your company can directly make contributions to your SIPP. These contributions are free from income tax and NICs while also being corporation tax deductible.
• Annual allowance: £60,000 (generally)
• Access: Money is locked until you turn 55 (rising to 57 in 2028).
• Tax on investments: Investments grow tax-free
• Withdrawal tax: 25% as a tax-free lump sum with the remainder taxed as income as and when withdrawn.

You can see some of the most important SIPP rules in the table below:
‍

ISA vs SIPP: Comparison for Business Owners

Unlike salaried employees, as a business owner, you have added flexibility when it comes to paying yourself tax-efficiently (salary, dividends etc) and in planning for retirement. ISAs and SIPPs offer different advantages depending on your preferences and goals. So, is a SIPP better than an ISA?

This table compares the accounts, showing the differences between SIPPs and ISAs on common areas:
‍

When an ISA is better than a SIPP

1. Flexibility and accessibility

If you’re looking for flexibility and accessibility, ISAs win. Unlike with a SIPP, in the vast majority of ISA cases, you can access your money instantly. This means an ISA is likely a better choice if you’re looking to invest but want this additional liquidity, perhaps to further grow your business, purchase property or to have on hand for emergencies.

In our dedicated articles, you can learn about the best Stocks and Shares ISAs and the best Cash ISAs.

2. Purchasing your first home

If you’re between 18 and 39 years old and planning to buy your first home, then don’t underestimate the benefits of a Lifetime ISA (LISA). Unlike a SIPP, funds in a LISA can be withdrawn to buy your first home. We compare the best Lifetime ISA accounts in another article but some key points on LISAs:

• The government adds a 25% bonus to your contributions.
• You may contribute to one LISA per tax year, a Cash LISA or Stocks and Shares LISA (not both).
• You can contribute up to £4,000 per year (the government adding a maximum bonus of £1,000). 
• Contributions count towards your overall ISA allowance (£20,000)
• You can only withdraw the money to buy your first home (up to £450,000) with a mortgage or for retirement (after age 60).
• Withdrawing outside the rules incurs a 25% penalty.
  ‍

When a SIPP is better than an ISA

1. Long-term, tax-efficient investing for directors

If you’re a director of a limited company looking to build long-term wealth, SIPPs win. Unlike with an ISA, one of the biggest tax benefits of a SIPP is that you can make employer contributions directly from your company. This offers a far more tax efficient method of extracting money from your company for investment when compared to earning it as a salary or dividend and then investing it personally. Here’s why:

• Allowable business expense: Contributions are seen as business expenses, which reduces your company's corporation tax bill. A £20,000 SIPP contribution could save your company between £3,800 and £5,000 in Corporation Tax (19% - 25%).
• No National Insurance: Unlike your salary, any employer contributions won’t be subject to employer or employee National Insurance contributions. Compared to taking the same in the form of salary, a £20,000 SIPP contribution could save £3,000 in Employer NICs (15%).
• No income or dividend tax: Unlike salaries or dividends, Employer contributions aren’t subject to the same income taxes. For a basic rate tax payer, this means a £20,000 contribution could save up to £4,000 of personal income tax + £1,200 of Class 4 NICs (compared to salary earnings) or up to £1,750 (compared to dividend earnings).
• Larger contribution limit: Your company may contribute up to your annual allowance of £60,000, subject to the wholly and exclusively rules (contributions must be for the purpose of business/as part of your remuneration).

2. Purchasing and protecting a business premises

One point that distinguishes a SIPP from an ISA is that you may use your SIPP funds to buy commercial property, including your own business premises. While using your SIPP for commercial property can further expand business operations it also allows for capital growth should the property appreciate. Further:

• Your business can rent the property from your SIPP, with the rent regularly adding to your pension pot (tax-free) and being another allowable expense you can use to reduce corporation tax. 
• This asset is safeguarded from creditors should something untoward occur because your business does not own the property. 
• You won’t pay Capital Gains Tax (CGT) on disposal of the property and it benefits from the same inheritance tax advantages since it is housed within the SIPP wrapper.

3. Tax-efficient retirement planning for sole traders & high earners

Unlike limited company directors, sole traders may not make employer contributions to their own SIPP. Fortunately, one of the other tax benefits of a SIPP pension is that any personal contributions you make will receive tax relief. 

HMRC automatically provides 20% tax relief on any personal SIPP contributions you make. Here is an example for a basic rate tax payer:

• You contribute £10,000 of your personal funds (post-tax) to your SIPP
• HMRC treats this as 80% of a gross contribution (£10,000/0.80 = £12,500) and adds £2,500 (20% of the gross amount)
• In short, your SIPP gains a £12,500 gross contribution at a net cost of £10,000

If you’re a higher rate (40%) or additional rate (45%) tax payer, you can claim the difference back (tax rebate) via self-assessment.

This relief is even more advantageous for higher and additional rate tax payers because post-lump sum withdrawals are taxed at your marginal rate, which ideally you’ll be able to control at that time (e.g. keep within the basic rate). Therefore, a higher rate payer could shift their eventual tax rate from 40% to 20% (provided the rates remain unchanged). And that’s without factoring in the 25% tax-free lump sum.
‍

Best of both worlds: ISA & SIPP

You could use both accounts in tandem, an ISA for flexibility and a SIPP for long-term tax relief and retirement security.

If you want to start looking at providers, learn more about the best SIPP for limited company directors or the top Stocks and Shares ISA accounts in our respective blog posts.

Here’s an example of how SIPPs and ISAs play out with a personal contribution of £10,000.
‍

Final Thoughts

For most UK entrepreneurs, it’s not so much a question of SIPP versus ISA, but how to employ both strategically. You could use ISAs for their added flexibility and liquidity while leveraging a SIPP for long-term, retirement planning and tax efficiency - especially if your business can contribute directly. This is one of the few remaining areas where business owners can tax-efficiently move funds from company profits into personal wealth.

Always speak to your accountant or financial advisor to ensure your contributions are structured in the most tax-efficient way possible. If you’re a client of ours, feel free to email your accountant on this. If you’re not a client yet and would like to work with us, please get in touch on this page.
‍

Remember, when you invest your capital at risk. Tax treatment depends on your individual circumstances and may be subject to change in the future. The value of your investments may go down as well as up. You may not get back all the money that you invest. This communication is not intended to be a personal recommendation. If you are unsure about the suitability of an investment product or service, you should seek advice from an authorised financial advisor.